The card type controls the rule
Visa explicitly says a debit card remains a debit card when the customer selects credit, which refers to signature versus PIN processing. Mastercard also excludes its debit and prepaid cards from permitted surcharges. Do not train staff to decide eligibility from the button a customer presses.
Test every channel
Request evidence of card-type handling for your terminal, payment link, keyed entry, website, and recurring billing workflow before enabling a surcharge. Include voids and refunds in the test plan. If a proposed setup cannot reliably exempt ineligible cards, do not approve that setup.
Frequently asked questions
What if a debit card has a Visa logo?
The logo does not make it a credit card. Visa’s debit-card surcharge prohibition still applies.
Are prepaid cards eligible?
No. The cited Visa and Mastercard surcharge rules exclude prepaid cards too.